ModVB FAQ
1 - Overview
1.1 What is ModVB?
1.2 Where does ModVB come from?
1.3 What is ASP?
1.4 What is VBScript?
1.5 Are there alternatives to Gnome Basic?
1.6 Are there alternatives to ModVB?
1.7 What are the aims of ModVB?
2 - Technical
2.1 What features does ModVB_support?
2.2 How much is ModVB different from Gnome Basic?
2.3 How was the code reworked?
2.4 What are classlibs?
2.5 Are sessions supported?
2.6 What about database support?
2.7 What ASP version does ModVB support?
2.8 Where can I find a good reference on ASP?
2.9 Where can I find more reference materials?
2.10 How is testing being done?
2.11 What about security?
3 - The Project
3.1 Do you accept patches/submissions?
3.2 Will feature XXX be implemented? When?
3.3 Can I write my own classlibs?
3.4 Will ModVB stay free software?
3.5 Are there any plans for Apache 2.x?
1.1
What is ModVB?
ModVB is a module for the Apache web server. It comes in the form of a DSO
(Dynamic Shared Object) which can be loaded when Apache is started. ModVB allows
your server to serve dynamic pages written according to the ASP specification
in what is the most widely used ASP language (i.e. VBScript).
1.2 Where does ModVB come from?
In 1998 Michael Meeks and other people started a project named Gnome
Basic, with the aim of building a MS Visual Basic work-alike for the Gnome
desktop. GB was meant as a full-fledged app, including Forms, Classes, a project
parser and all the tools needed to run actual VB programs. Preliminary support
for ASP compatibility was somehow present in the project but, anyway, GB never
reached the state of maturity. A few months after the Mono
project was started, GB was declared "dead" for good, since, for the
task of running VB apps, a much better alternative was available. Marco
Ridoni started
from where GB was left, but quite in a different direction, and mod_gb was born.
After having difficulty in reaching Marco and needing lots of changes while seeing
the potential of mod_gb, Trinity Bays forked the project and created ModVb.
For more details, see 2.3 How was the code reworked?
1.3 What is ASP?
ASP is the acronym for Active Server Pages, a Microsoft technology which allows
to serve dynamic content from a web server (IIS, Microsoft Intern Information
Services), in a fashion very similar to Apache
when coupled with PHP, Perl, Python or CGI programs. The ASP specification,
in its version 2.0 defines five "objects" (Application, Session, Request,
Server and Response) which are used to manage different parts of the web request
processing. ASP 3.0 added several extensions to VBScript and more objects.
1.4 What is VBScript?
It is common knowledge that ASP == VBScript. Wrong. ASP is simply a specification
for a web programming environment which can be used by several languages. VBScript
is certainly the most popular, but ASP pages can also be written in JScript
(Microsoft's own version of Javascript) and there is also a Perl module (Apache::ASP)
which allows you to use the ASP objects from Perl.
VBScript is a subset
of Visual basic for Applications, which in turn is a subset of Visual Basic.
The syntax stays the same for the most part, the most notable difference being
that the only type of variable available in VBScript is "Variant". ModVB, at least for now, supports some Visual basic extensions, owing to its
origin.
1.5 Are there alternatives to Gnome Basic?
If you need to run VB programs under Linux/*nix, there is no alternative that
I know of. But the Mono project is progressing at a steady pace, so keep looking.
1.6 Are there alternatives to ModVB?
If you need to run ASP/VBScript pages under Linux here and now there are two
commercial alternatives: Sun
One Active Server Pages (previously known as Chili!Soft ASP) and Stryon
InstantASP 2.1 (previously known as Halcyon InstantASP). Both are quite
expensive (US$ 495 and 995 respectively) but seem to do their job quite well.
Of course they're closed source.
1.7
What are the aims of ModVB?
ModVB aims at being fully compatible with ASP/VBScript/JScript and at being a tool
able to ease the migration towards free/open-source solutions. Many people in
the free software community are scared of the possibility that as the level
of compatibility with closed/commercial solutions increases, the role of free
software and the possibility of having "strong" free-software applications
are both diminished. On the other side a tool like ModVB, when at a stable
state, will allow to migrate your web applications towards a free (both as in
"free speech" and in "free beer") environment in a more
gradual way. Most sysadmins I know (includeing myself, of course) would scrap
their WinNT/IIS server this very moment; but they simply can't, because there
are too many apps (and too many clients) out there who need/want ASP/VBScript
support. While a major rework of a given web site could be the chance to move
it to, say, PHP or mod_perl, you simply can't throw out of the window (no pun
intended...) thousands of lines of ASP code which was probably fully debugged
and paid for.
2.1
What features does ModVB_support?
All the ASP 2.0 standard objects (Application, Request, Response, Server, Sessions)
are supported. This doesn't mean that all their properties/methods are there,
but that they are properly instantiated and are available at runtime. More properties
and methods are being added. I have ported first those objects and associated/methods/properties
which I believe are more widely in use or possibly useful. For now, this is
a list of what is currently working:
Request: Cookies,
Form, QueryString, ServerVariables
Response: Write
Server: CreateObject, MapPath, HTMLEncode*, URLEncode*
Session: Item
Application: N/A
* these are stubs which return the same parameter passed to them
For what it concerns
classlibs (see 2.4):
ADODB supports Connection and Recordset obejcts with a few Basic methods:
Connection: Open, Close, ConnectionString
Recordset: Open, Close, MoveNext, MoveFirst,
Update
FileSystemObject supports the File and TextStream objects with enough methods
to read a file from a local filesystem.
2.2 How much is ModVB different from Gnome Basic?
The core of ModVB is an almost direct recompile (read below) of the old GB
core (interpreter + runtime + runtime library) with several features added (i.e.
object instancing a-la Set MyObject = New MyClass was still missing)
and several bugs ironed out.
2.3 How was the code reworked?
ModVB uses a different/simpler build system (I plan to reintroduce autoconf
in a not-too-distant future) from GB. More notably, the whole code base was ported
from GTK+ 1.2/X11 to GLib 2.0 (particularly the type system) in order to eliminate
the dependencies on X11 and Gnome (which were actually minimal)
2.4 What are classlibs?
Classlibs are external shared libraries which are loaded dynamically when the
module handler starts up. They're somewhat similar to Microsoft ASP Objects/ActiveX
classlibs and contain object definitions and code which can be instantiated
and used by user ASP code (with the Server.CreateObject method). I chose this
approach in order to keep ModVB as modular as possible. Moreover this will
allow to restrict access to some classlibs for a given virtual server on Apache.
2.5 Are sessions supported?
Yes, with some limitations; currently it is possible to store only string-data
(and data which can be promoted to String type) in Session.Item's. To store
objects or, at least, arrays, a serializer/deserializer is needed and planned.
2.6 What about database support?
ModVB supports databases thru unixODBC,
so any DB which has a driver for this library should work. Tests are currently
done on MySQL and Postgresql .
2.7 What ASP version does ModVB support?
Version 2.0, but take it with caution and a grain of salt, since a few things
do not make sense on *nix platforms. Anyway class support (ASP 3.0 level) is
on the table and scheduled for inclusion soon.
2.8 Where can I find a good reference on ASP?
Well, I suppose Microsoft's MSDN is
the primary reference for ASP programming, but also sites like www.15seconds.com,
www.asp101.com can be useful. Anyway, Google
is your friend... :-)
2.9 Where can I find more support/reference materials?
ModVB/GB code is documented where possible but, unfortunately, a good reference
on its internals is lacking, so you will have to study the code or ask a few
questions. There are two mailing
lists devoted to this task.
2.10 How is testing being done?
I am the designer/programmer/maintainer/whatever of several ASP sites which make
heavy use of databases, sessions, etc. I'm using my own code to test ModVB,
trying to leave it unmodified (apart from obvious things like connection strings,
filesystem paths, etc.), in order to test compliance with "real" ASP
behavior. When more features will be present, I plan to test how some common
toolkits (forums, e-commerce apps) work.
2.11 What about security?
ModVB currently is not geared towards security, but in a stable version,
this will be cared for in due manner. Please keep in mind that the great majority
of attacks against IIS servers exploit holes in the server itself, and not in
the ASP engine. As Apache is reasonably secure, this should lead to some degree
of confidence.
3.1
Do you accept patches/submissions?
No. Well, sort of. Currently, ModVB's code base is a moving target, with a lot
of code being reworked, removed or added, so I prefer to be free to mess with
the code until ModVB reaches a more stable state. This does NOT mean, of course,
that if you discover a bug, have some idea or have coded a patch or an extension,
you should keep it for yourself. Contact
me or use the mailing
lists instead.
3.2 Will feature XXX be implemented? When?
So far there is not a real roadmap but one can still ask (I said ask, not request
or demand... :-) )
3.3 Can I write my own classlibs?
Yes, of course. As soon as possible I will put online a tutorial with sources.
Anyway you can look at the code for current classlib implementations and try
to reuse that.
3.4 Will ModVB stay free software?
Of course it will! I couldn't make it proprietary even if I wanted (and I absolutely
DON'T want this). This means that source will always be freely available for
you to view, modify, criticize, destroy, etc.
3.5 Are there any plans for Apache 2.x?
Not right now, since Apache 2.0 API is very different from its 1.3.x counterpart
(thread model, different module structure, different handles and a gazillion
of other differences) but surely I will take a stab at it in the future.
|